Massachusetts: Malpractice Payment of $495,000 for Injury to a Female Patient in her 20s (2019)

In 2019, a medical malpractice insurance company made a payment on behalf of a physician (MD) in Massachusetts for approximately* $495,000. Payment was made in response to a claim of medical malpractice claim involving what was described as an emotional injury to a female patient between 20 and 30 years old. The nature of the claim is broadly described as: "treatment related." The payment report submitted by Unreported described the allegations in the claim as "Improper Conduct."

* The payment amount is approximate because the National Practitioner Data Bank codes payments as a range value. The report's description of $495,000 corresponds to a malpractice payment somewhere between $490,001 and $500,000.

Claim at a Glance

Year of Payment: 2019

Location: Massachusetts

Allegation: Improper Conduct

Act or Omission: 2015

Payment Range: Between $490,001 and $500,000

Nature of Claim: Treatment Related

Payer: Insurance Company - Primary Coverage

Type of Care: Outpatient

Reporter: Unreported

Claim Insights

With respect to any medical malpractice payment, there are three major components of any claim. First, there is the act or omission that gave rise to an injury and whether the provider departed from an accepted standard of practice. Second, there is the nature of the injury itself, which includes several factors like its severity, duration, the impact on the patient’s life, the age and general health of the patient, along with many other elements. Third, there needs to be a causal connection between the negligent act or omission by the provider and the injury itself. Even with a showing of negligence, a medical provider is not legally responsible for an outcome that was not caused by the negligence.

With this in mind, the Data Bank does have some information that can give context to the medical malpractice payments, including the patient’s age, gender, whether it was inpatient or outpatient care, the type of malpractice or medical mistake that was alleged, and the ultimate outcome to the patient.

The information has significant limitations, however, that everyone should keep in mind. For one thing, the information is usually self-reported by the healthcare provider and his or her representatives. When reviewing this information, you should consider whether the patient would have described his or her injury as “minor” or “temporary” or “emotional only.” Further, there are important aspects of any claim valuation that simply cannot work in a database. Flagrant negligence might be coded the same way as what could be described as a smaller error, and one would have no way of knowing from these data. But even with these limitations and even where some required information is missing from any particular report, each of the payment reports in the database have enough to provide some insightful information that can help evaluate medical malpractice claims going forward.

Provider History Includes Two Licensure Reports

A medical provider's malpractice history can be extremely insightful. A long history of malpractice claims and discipline can certainly affect whether a matter is resolved and for how much. One of the most important goals of the National Practitioner Data Bank is to track providers' disciplinary and malpractice payment history throughout interstate moves or new employment situations.

In addition to this particular malpractice payment, this provider has three other types of reports on record that are worth noting. First, this provider has a total of six malpractice payments in the database. This is a highly concerning number of medical malpractice payments. To put this number in perspective, throughout over 200,000 payment records, approximately 55% of them are associated with providers with multiple payments. This provider's total of six malpractice payments is more than 96% of all providers in the database, which is limited to providers with malpractice payment history.

Second, the database reflects that this particular provider had two licensure report(s) on record. These are more unusual among the providers for whom malpractice payments are recorded in the database - only about 15% of the providers with malpractice payments also have at least one licensure report as well.

Third, this provider has a DEA report on record. There are a number of reasons why the DEA would take action against a provider, including prescription practices or requiring oversight with controlled substances. There are only 69 payment reports (.03%) in the entire database associated with any provider with even one such report on record.

Provider Detail

Alerts 9

Massachusetts

Physician (MD)

Age: Between 50 and 60 Years Old in 2015 When Allegations Arose

Education Completed: Between 1980 and 1990

Malpractice Payments 6
There are other payments in the database associated with this provider:
YearStateAmountAllegation
2019Massachusetts$145,000Improper Conduct
2019Massachusetts$495,000Sexual Misconduct
2019Massachusetts$245,000Sexual Misconduct
2019Massachusetts$495,000Improper Conduct
2020Massachusetts$175,000Sexual Misconduct
2023Massachusetts$225,000Improper Conduct
Licensure Reports 2
Adverse actions by the state licensing board are reported to the NPDB. Some of these actions are public, but some are not. All adverse actions must be reported in this database, whether or not they are public.
DEA Reports 1
These reports are submitted when the Drug Enforcement Administration takes action based on controlled substance registration.
Payments

Similar Claims

Here are other claims involving an allegation of Improper Conduct and an outcome of what was described as an emotional injury to a patient between 20 and 30 years old.
YearStateAmountAllegation
2024New York$72,500Improper Conduct
2023Georgia$22,500Improper Conduct
2022California$2,500Improper Conduct
2021Colorado$125,000Improper Conduct
2021Missouri$17,500Improper Conduct
2020California$645,000Improper Conduct
2020Indiana$6,250Improper Conduct
2020Texas$17,500Improper Conduct
2019North Carolina$8,750Improper Conduct
2019North Carolina$17,500Improper Conduct